Skip to content
site-logo

Novelistic Pages

  • About Me
  • Bookshelf
  • About Me
  • Bookshelf
book review

Catching Feelings by Maren Moore | Book Review

April 1, 2024April 1, 2024 Novelistic Pages 2 comments

Maren Moore is an indie author who was new to me this year. The first book in the series, Homerun Proposal, caught my eye on Kindle Unlimited a while ago, and I finally borrowed it earlier this month. I was OBSESSED. It was my first baseball romance, and I had such a good time.

When I saw on Instagram that digital ARC were going out for Book 2, Catching Feelings, I knew I had to put a request in. I was so happy when I saw I was approved for the ARC. I have quite a few thoughts, so let’s get into it!

Catching Feelings can already be purchased online or borrowed on Kindle Unlimited.

GENERAL INFO

Catching Feelings by Maren Moore | Book ReviewCatching Feelings by Maren Moore
Series: Orleans University #2
Published on March 22, 2024
Genres: Adult, Romance, Spicy, Sports Romance
Pages: 356
Format: ARC, eBook
Buy on Amazon
Goodreads

Reese Landry is Orleans University’s arrogant, All-Star catcher. And I’m the one girl he can’t seem to catch. If anything, it only makes him want me more.

He’s disgustingly rich, stupidly charming, and everyone loves him. Except me.

But then life throws me the ultimate curveball: He’s my new temporary roomie. I thought it was going to be easy, keeping him at a distance. Turns out, I was wrong.

He’s nothing like the cocky, rich playboy that I thought he was. I told myself one more time wouldn’t hurt. We promised to keep things casual, no strings attached. But soon lines blur, and he somehow becomes my only safe space to land.

And now, we’re catching feelings.

Spicy rating: 🌶🌶🌶🌶🌶

The Tropes:

  • black cat X cinnamon roll
  • and they were roommates
  • forced proximity
  • grief rep
  • he falls first

Catching Feelings follows two characters–Reese and Viv–who were both introduced in the first book in the series, Homerun Proposal. I was excited to learn more about Viv, especially since she was such a strong friend to Hallie in the first book.

Pros

  • I think the strongest part of this book was the spicy scenes. Right away, the book starts off strong with a first-chapter spicy scene and WOW. It blew me away.

“I wish I didn’t know what she tasted like, or the little sounds she makes when she’s about to come, or how it felt to sink inside of her and lose myself.”

  • Like are you kidding me?!?!? This made me literally swoon out loud. There is no doubt about it–Maren Moore can write a spicy scene.
  • Reese was my favorite character by far. He was sweet, caring, and HOT (iykyk). He is honestly the reason I kept reading this book. Maybe I have a soft spot for rich baseball players who spoil their girlfriends, but I was in love with Reese the entire time.

Cons

  • I think this is becoming one of my least favorite part of romance books, but cheesy nicknames?? I’m sorry, but I could not help but cringe every time I read the words “Sweet Tart.” Maybe once or twice, but when it comes up repeatedly throughout a book, I can’t.
  • This is not necessarily a con as it is a major letdown. I did not like the development of Viv in this book. I think her background and struggles could have made her a very strong character, but I never really felt like she learned from her life or even properly grappled with everything that happened to her. Part of this is because of the writing for her character. Paragraphs of dialogue does not mean a character is processing something…there needs to be more!
  • Which brings me to my last con: the dialogue. Whenever Viv and Reece talked to each other about something important, it was mostly just dialogue. It felt very one-dimensional because it was hard to imagine how the two characters were interacting.

Overall Thoughts

While I really enjoyed book one in the series, book two fell short for me. I didn’t feel any connection to the characters, and if the spicy scenes were taken out, I don’t think I would have enjoyed most of it. It really breaks my heart since I loved book one so much, but I will not give up! I definitely plan on reading more by Maren Moore in the future.

After seeing other reviews, I think I am definitely in the minority here. I would recommend you give the book a chance if you are into any of the tropes listed above. However, I highly recommend you read book one, Homerun Proposal.

Final Rating: 2.25 stars


Those are all of my thoughts on Catching Feelings. Are you interested in picking this one up?

Be sure to also answer the question of the day! I love seeing what you guys are loving in the book world!

Until next time, xx

Question of the Day:

What book are you currently reading?

Share the love:

  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • More
  • Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • Share on Reddit (Opens in new window) Reddit
  • Share on Pinterest (Opens in new window) Pinterest

Like this:

Like Loading…

Related

arc reviewbaseball romancebook blogbook bloggerbook bloggingbook reviewbookishcatching feelingsmaren moorereviewspicy bookspicy romancesports romance
About Kenn

About Kenn

I’m Kenn, a 26 year old English teacher with a huge passion for literature. I read a little of everything but my favorite genres are probably Thrillers, Contemporary Romance, and YA Fantasy. Besides loving reading, I am a huge horror movie fan (it is pretty much all I watch) and my cat is my best friend.

Related Posts

Dive Bar at the End of the Road | Book Review
Dive Bar at the End of the Road | Book Review
Recent NetGalley Reads | August – September 2026
Recent NetGalley Reads | August – September 2026
In What World by Bridget Morrissey | Book Review
In What World by Bridget Morrissey | Book Review
Book Club Boyfriend by Jenny Holiday | Book Review
Book Club Boyfriend by Jenny Holiday | Book Review

Post navigation

Full of Myself by Siobhan Gallagher | Graphic Novel Review
Darling Girls by Sally Hepworth | Book Review

2 comments

  1. Pingback: The Sunday Post | Reading and Blog Recaps
  2. Pingback: End-of-Year Check-In: 2024 Reading Goals – Novelistic Pages

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Hey, there!

Hey, there!

I read a little of everything but my favorite genres are probably Romance and Horror.

Besides loving reading, I love horror movies (it is pretty much all I watch), Star Wars, cozy gaming, and crocheting ✨

Follow on WordPress.com

Recent Reviews

Dive Bar at the End of the Road by Kelley ArmstrongOne of the Family by Mark EdwardsTo All the Boys I've Loved Before (Graphic Novel Edition) by Jenny HanMigrant Heart by Reyna GrandeRun for the Hills by Kevin WilsonShip Happens by Mason DeaverIn What World by Bridget MorrisseyBook Club Boyfriend by Jenny HolidayThe House of Now and Then by Edward UnderhillThe Other Side of Now by Paige HarbisonEverything She Does Is Magic by Bridget MorrisseyThe Dahlia Suite by Carinn Jade

NEVER MISS A POST

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 156 other subscribers

2026 Reading Challenge

2026 Reading Challenge
Kennedy has

read 0 books toward her goal of 80 books.

hide

0 of 80 (0%)
view books

Goodreads

  • anticipated releases
  • Book Blogger Hop
  • book challenge
  • book review
  • book tag
  • books
  • Discussions
  • Goodreads Monday
  • reading stats
  • Recently Read
  • tbr
  • The Sunday Post
  • Top 10 Tuesday
  • Weekly Memes
  • WWW Wednesday

Featured Book Reviewer
Professional Reader

  • About Me
  • Bookshelf

Novelistic Pages

Novelistic Pages © 2026 | All Rights ReservedDesigned by Little Theme Shop
Loading Comments...
%d